Guides & Resources
Amanda Rose Exposes Fake Business Coaches: What Australian Small Business Owners Should Know
Discover what Amanda Rose's discussion on fake business coaches means for Australian small business owners,
Covering cash flow, compliance, and growth.
The growth of social media has made business advice more accessible than ever before.
Alongside experienced advisers, accountants, and industry professionals, there has also been a rapid increase in self-described business coaches promoting strategies for rapid business growth.
During a recent interview, Australian business commentator Amanda Rose discussed concerns surrounding the business coaching industry, highlighting the importance of practical business fundamentals, financial discipline, and long-term execution over short-term trends.
While many coaches provide valuable accountability and strategic support, business owners should understand the differences between operational coaching, regulated professional advice, and specialist accounting or tax services.
For Australian small business owners operating in an increasingly competitive environment, choosing the right advisers can play an important role in managing cash flow, compliance, profitability, and long-term business success.
What Happened?
Amanda Rose recently shared her views on the current business coaching landscape in Australia.
During the discussion, she raised several observations regarding the increasing popularity of online coaching programs and social media-driven business advice.
Key topics discussed included:
- The business coaching industry remains largely unregulated in Australia.
- Social media popularity does not necessarily demonstrate commercial expertise.
- Constantly changing business strategies can prevent consistent execution.
- Business owners should prioritise financial preparation before transitioning into self-employment.
- Sustainable business growth is typically built through consistent operational improvements rather than chasing trends.
The discussion has prompted broader conversations around how Australian business owners evaluate professional advice and make long-term business decisions.
Why Does This Matter?
External advisers can significantly influence how business owners approach pricing, growth, staffing, marketing, and financial management.
When professional advice produces measurable improvements, it can generate substantial value.
However, if businesses invest heavily in services that fail to improve profitability or operational performance, those expenses can reduce available working capital and affect cash flow.
For many Australian businesses facing rising operating costs, inflation, and ongoing Australian Taxation Office (ATO) compliance obligations, ensuring that professional advice delivers genuine commercial outcomes is increasingly important.
Why Small Business Owners Should Pay Attention
Business owners often engage external advisers to improve:
- Business growth
- Operational efficiency
- Marketing performance
- Leadership skills
- Financial management
- Accountability
While these services may provide value, business owners should understand where coaching ends and regulated professional advice begins.
Tax planning, business structures, GST obligations, payroll, and many compliance matters should only be handled by appropriately qualified professionals.
Understanding these distinctions can reduce compliance risks while improving decision-making.
Who Should Pay Attention?
Several groups may benefit from reviewing how they obtain business advice.
Small Business Owners
Businesses currently investing in coaching or consulting services should regularly assess whether those services are producing measurable commercial outcomes.
New Entrepreneurs
Individuals preparing to launch a business should ensure they have realistic financial plans and adequate cash reserves before leaving secure employment.
Contractors and Sole Traders
Independent operators should ensure business advice aligns with their actual operating costs, pricing model, and tax obligations.
Company Directors
Business leaders making structural or strategic decisions should ensure specialist accounting and legal advice is obtained where required.
What Are the Tax and Business Implications?
Professional Advice vs Regulated Advice
Business coaching generally focuses on accountability, leadership, marketing, or operational improvement.
However, advice relating to tax, business structures, GST, trust distributions, or legal compliance may require a registered tax agent or qualified legal practitioner.
Obtaining advice from appropriately qualified professionals helps reduce regulatory risks and potential ATO penalties.
Business Coaching Expenses
Business coaching expenses may generally be tax deductible where they directly relate to operating an existing business and producing assessable income.
However, businesses should regularly evaluate whether those expenses contribute to measurable improvements in areas such as:
- Revenue growth
- Gross profit
- Net profit
- Operational efficiency
- Cash flow
Monitoring these outcomes can help determine whether coaching remains a worthwhile business investment.
Cash Flow Management
Professional service expenses should always be considered alongside broader cash flow priorities.
Business owners should continue allocating sufficient funds toward:
- Tax obligations
- Superannuation
- Payroll
- Equipment investment
- Emergency cash reserves
- Business growth initiatives
Maintaining healthy liquidity often provides greater long-term resilience than continually investing in new programs without measurable returns.
What Should Business Owners Do Now?
Rather than reacting to online trends, business owners should focus on practical business management.
Review External Service Providers
Assess whether advisers are delivering measurable improvements aligned with your business objectives.
Measure Return on Investment
Compare consulting and coaching costs against improvements in profitability, productivity, or operational performance.
Build Financial Resilience
Establish sufficient cash reserves before expanding operations or transitioning into full-time self-employment.
Focus on Consistency
Long-term business success is often built through disciplined execution, regular financial reviews, and continuous operational improvement.
Seek Qualified Professional Advice
Where tax, compliance, business structuring, or financial planning is involved, consult appropriately qualified professionals.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
Assuming Social Media Authority Equals Technical Expertise
Online visibility does not necessarily demonstrate expertise in accounting, taxation, business structures, or compliance.
Making Structural Decisions Without Professional Advice
Changes involving companies, trusts, partnerships, or asset ownership should be reviewed by qualified advisers.
Constantly Changing Strategies
Frequently abandoning proven business processes in favour of new trends may reduce long-term consistency.
Neglecting Compliance
Business Activity Statements (BAS), payroll obligations, superannuation, and tax lodgements remain essential regardless of broader business growth initiatives.
Measuring Activity Instead of Results
Professional advice should ultimately contribute to measurable business outcomes rather than simply generating additional meetings or courses.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. Are business coaching fees tax-deductible?
In many cases, yes. Coaching expenses relating to operating an existing business may be deductible if they are incurred in producing assessable income.
2. Can business coaches provide tax advice?
Business coaches may provide general business guidance, but tax advice should be obtained from a registered tax agent.
3. Is business coaching regulated in Australia?
Unlike accounting, law, and financial advice, business coaching is generally not subject to a specific national regulatory framework.
4. Should business owners verify a coach’s experience?
Yes. Reviewing professional experience, client references, and measurable business outcomes is considered good practice.
5. How can I measure whether coaching is worthwhile?
Review improvements in profitability, revenue, operational efficiency, and business performance over time.
6. Should I rely solely on online business advice?
Online resources can provide useful information, but important financial and legal decisions should be supported by qualified professionals.
7. How much cash reserve should a business maintain?
Many businesses aim to maintain between three and six months of operating expenses, depending on their industry and circumstances.
8. What professional advice requires specialist qualifications?
Tax advice, business structuring, trust planning, legal matters, and financial advice should generally be obtained from appropriately qualified professionals.
9. How often should business performance be reviewed?
Many businesses benefit from reviewing financial performance monthly or quarterly alongside their accountant or adviser.
10. What contributes to sustainable business growth?
Consistent execution, sound financial management, effective cash flow, strong compliance practices, and informed decision-making remain key drivers of long-term business success.
Final Thoughts
Amanda Rose’s discussion has contributed to a broader conversation about how Australian business owners evaluate external advice and build successful businesses.
While coaching and mentoring can provide valuable support, long-term business success is generally built on strong financial management, consistent execution, sound operational processes, and informed decision-making.
For many businesses, combining practical business guidance with qualified accounting and tax advice provides the strongest foundation for sustainable growth.
Need Help Building a Strong Financial Foundation?
If you are unsure how your business is performing, or would like guidance on cash flow, profitability, tax planning, or business structures, speak with Latitude Accountants.
Our team can help you understand your options, stay compliant, and make better business decisions with confidence.
๐ Sydney Olympic Park | Marrickville | Melbourne | Loxton
๐ 1300 706 597
๐ง info@latitudeaccountants.com.au
Disclaimer
This article is general information only and does not constitute tax, legal, financial, or business advice. Information is based on publicly available discussions and commentary available at the time of writing. Individual circumstances vary, and professional advice should be obtained before making financial or business decisions.
Free Consultation
Got questions after reading this?
Book a call with our team. We'll walk through your situation and help you understand your options โ no obligation.
Book Your Free Consultation*Free for all ABN holders ยท Limited spots available
Call 1300 706 597What We Do
Chartered accountants who work proactively
Not just at tax time โ all year round.
Before You Make a Move
Six times you should call us first
Most costly mistakes happen before the paperwork is signed.
Buying a vehicle
Structure, FBT, and depreciation all need to be right before you sign.
Taking money out
Wages, dividends, or drawings each carry different tax consequences.
Buying property
Who buys it changes your GST, land tax, and CGT position entirely.
Hiring your first employee
Payroll, super, and STP obligations kick in from day one.
Buying or selling a business
You can inherit someone else's tax debt. Know what you're buying first.
Taking on a partner
Equity splits need proper structure upfront. A handshake deal costs more to unwind.
Get In Touch
Stop Guessing. Start Making Better Decisions.
Get clarity on your numbers, your structure, and your next move. Speak directly with our team and walk away knowing exactly where you stand.